: ***
Still would ruin the game for new people, and the people who the individual inted for.
: Off meta picks ain't bannable... She fed 1 out of all those games. Just cause she has 10 losses in row doesn't mean she is getting banned..
You didn’t read the part where this person says that the syndra picked up the jungler’s buffs and threw them away resetting them and thus ruining the experience for everyone in the game.
De Kus (EUW)
: Once is always the first time. Without a first time, there is no second time. I agree about "Intentionally de-ranking", but how to detect/prove? Is Boosted/Bought account really so much of an issue? After getting boosted more than 1 liga, I am pretty sure playing on that account becomes pretty frustating. They punish themselves by playing against stronger opponents. Banning Off-meta makes no sense. Off-meta can be actually pretty good, especially in low and average elo. A lethality poppy has immense assasination potentional, if Veigar goes tank and buys a void staff, his R still does a lot of missing HP scaling damage and scales AP through his passive. Off-meta build is not only accaptable, but might also give a surprsing turn to the game. Especially since meta build is expected, and I can tell from my experience, other players rarely change their playstyle after you buying off meta. Like Zed still tries to pick Janna, even though she has become much to tanky to be assasinated. PowerOfEvil was also never banned in pro play for playing Orianna with {{item:3115}} which is afaik. considered off meta till today (even though the synergy with her passive on paper is obvious). So what exactly is a troll build? Well I assume buying 6 {{item:1027}} on an energy champion or 6 {{item:1051}} on a mage is obvious. Building AP Vayne also makes no sense, the AP on her E does not make it playable and is more or less just to improve the benefit of rageblade stacking. But what about attack speed Braum vs. another melee? It's not like you cannot win such a game, just because you go for an off meta build. Some times just building the same items every game can be worse than doing something creative like buying {{item:3194}} and {{item:3009}} to chase a Singed. But just trying a build and see if it works in that particular is not a reason for a ban, even if a majority would vote that idea as stupid.
I guess you did not read the top part where I said its for ranked only, and we can both agree that first timing a champion in ranked is guaranteed in a loss. Boosted/Bought account is a big issue, especially when players from iron and bronze think they are hard stuck because of teammates then they think they are faker buy a diamond account and ruin the experience for everyone, and honestly since you only lose 10lp per game it's flawed af, the player with the bought account couldn't get to iron if he inted every game because of the way the system is setup. I guess you really influenced the game with your first time vi jungle game, I checked your profile you first timed vi and lost lp for everyone on your team that game, idc about normals btw because they should in no way influence ranked balance decisions. There is good off-meta and bad, good is the taric sona which saw competitive play and high elo play, but when you decide to first time lethality Caitlyn in the mid lane and int your ass off you deserve some sort of punishment, not to mention how poppy is completely useless late game with lethality, just because you see your favourite streamer play it in a normal games does not justify you inting everyone on your team, same can be said about other off meta picks which are not being practiced in higher levels of play. The last point you make, makes no sense because it largely depends on the enemy champions and the champion you are playing. But you spam normal games, (which isn't wrong) so you should for sure not have a say in which builds are good / not.
: Just had a game with this person. Ruined the game for the other 9 people and all this for what ? just because he/her is mad about somehting that happened in the passed ? it really is sad if you think about it. wrote a ticket to riot and i hope other do the same so that we can prove the system is working P.S: has been doing it now for a coupld of games over maybe 3 hours and already this person is claiming the system is not working xD. just shows how big the issue is more of a personal matter and he/her just decided to drag ther rest with her into lower elo
: > [{quoted}](name=doby flonk u mom,realm=EUNE,application-id=NzaqEm3e,discussion-id=7EzmtrKy,comment-id=000500000000,timestamp=2019-11-06T12:08:24.929+0000) > > That MF made a mistake to stay with such low hp, if she makes that mistake more than 8 times in 10 fkin minutes I think it's deserving of a ban And that's the key word there: "mistake". Everyone makes mistakes and yet you intend to punish people for their mistakes by banning them, on the very small chance that they are intentionally feeding. Aside from the obvious smurfing problems there are some other things to consider that make you unqualified to judge if someone is inting or not. 1. You have very limited information of what is going on. There is no way you can get a 100% clear idea of what is happening in another lane whilst you are playing yourself. You might see snippets of things but you will always miss something. 2. You don't know all the lane match-ups. Certain lane match-ups can snowball out of control very quickly and unless you are intimately familiar with the match-up in question, you haven't the knowledge or experience to judge someone else's play. This kind of thing happens all the time. What annoys me the most is when people who have never played my champion try to tell me how to play.
The key word there is 8 time in 10 minutes, you dont make THE SAME %%%%ING MISTAKE 8 times in a row bro stop fkin defending this shit
: dude, really? i have to explain to you why purposedly ruining other people games in ranked is bad? >When the system lets you manipulate it however you want to why not take advantage of that? oh, ok, the system has some flaws so let's all be total %%%%heads because the system allows it, right? i mean, the system doesn't prevent me to do it, so why shouldn't i be a douche? %%%% behaving like decent player/human being, the system isn't enforcing me to do it, so why would i put the huge amount of effort of behaving correctly?? i mean, it's so much stress to not int games for random players, right?? pfft. and the whole argument of "i'm inting just to prove a point" is total bullshit, if it were true he would send a support ticket and close the account and proceeded to play normally after a few inting games, instead of keeping an account just to mess with people when in the mood. and it's not like you have to prove it aniway, everybody knows you can trick the system
Its actually %%%%ing comical bro, even they know that fkin bot is checking these reports so they put blitz on there https://gyazo.com/8a011f1b9a54be92505223f5a4119e6b Their whole behviour team is 2 dudes and 1 AI, it's legit so fkin useless, you will see their response being useless as well.
: dude, really? i have to explain to you why purposedly ruining other people games in ranked is bad? >When the system lets you manipulate it however you want to why not take advantage of that? oh, ok, the system has some flaws so let's all be total %%%%heads because the system allows it, right? i mean, the system doesn't prevent me to do it, so why shouldn't i be a douche? %%%% behaving like decent player/human being, the system isn't enforcing me to do it, so why would i put the huge amount of effort of behaving correctly?? i mean, it's so much stress to not int games for random players, right?? pfft. and the whole argument of "i'm inting just to prove a point" is total bullshit, if it were true he would send a support ticket and close the account and proceeded to play normally after a few inting games, instead of keeping an account just to mess with people when in the mood. and it's not like you have to prove it aniway, everybody knows you can trick the system
You know what, I will send a support ticket and Ill be back with the response :)
: She was not staying, she was actually running away after a bad encounter. I only caught up with her, killed her and retreated into the bush near Krugs. All in all, this was a story about how easy diving is when you have the right champion. Sure, dying again and again in the same place is stupid and probably intentional. But almost _any kind_ of automated banning rule is going to fail and to be abused in such a complex environment as League of Legends.
TRIBUNAL SYSTEM ALL OTHER GAMES WITH PERMA BANS HAVE THIS SYSTEM jesus christ it feels like riot are intentionally not creating justice.
: > "sit under turret and farm safely" Ah right, dived a retreating low HP MF just recently with Hecarim — right through the tower that's been attacking me. E, Predator, couple of hits, Q, free kill! Mind you, no ulti. And I even haven't been specially fed or way below my level.
That MF made a mistake to stay with such low hp, if she makes that mistake more than 8 times in 10 fkin minutes I think it's deserving of a ban
Flow1999 (EUNE)
: > [{quoted}](name=Sir Prepuzius,realm=EUW,application-id=NzaqEm3e,discussion-id=7EzmtrKy,comment-id=00000000000000000001,timestamp=2019-11-06T11:17:13.581+0000) > > you are the worst kind of troll, and an hypocrite too since i bet you didn't write a support ticket to riot asking them to look at your profile am i right? > > you have no right to complain about anything in this game since YOU are the problem, not riot. Why would he.. what kinda of logic is that? When the system lets you manipulate it however you want to why not take advantage of that? He can still say "I should not be able to do that but here I am ruining others experience and you are doing nothing about it". He can still have opinion about it. You can't blame the playerbase for the lack of regulations, you can't expect everyone to be a perfect human being when they are literaly no reprocussions for being an asshole as long as you don't type anything in chat.
Amazing response, couldnt have said it better myself, thanks.
Câstiél (EUW)
: I checked it. Maybe people aren't reporting you at all, who knows. Where is your response on my arguments? EDIT: Scores like 1/4 0/3 are completely alright. And still: A system like you proposed wouldn't detect the case in your screenshot.
Еvery single game I announced that I was inting, and every single person in the game flamed and said that they would report me, sad thing is that I got some people banned for this, and yet im still not banned. I take jungler's buff with syndra w and they cant play jungle, I also leave support alone, this is so cancer and they still arent banning me idk what to say tbh
Câstiél (EUW)
: A system like you proposed wouldn't detect that case. In addition, scores like that are no reason to ban someone - unless it's clear that the person is inting and is not on a crazy losing streak. It is really hard to find cases that are actually intentionally feeding, by the amount of games played in total. But I do agree, constant scores like 0/8/0 should be banned by a system, at least if there are similar scores like that for the majority of games. But honestly, almost noone ints every game. The dangerous / problematic players are the ones who play normal and just int once every 10 games or something like that. Because that's inting which is extremely hard to detect for a system, but this behavior is in fact toxic.
Check the screenshot, I am continuing to do this and where is the ban on that account?
: score matters but is not the main objective, you can get all kills in the world you want and still lose bcs you didnt push.
Then you lose lp and learn that next time you get a lead you should abuse that lead, the fact of the matter is that score gives you a massive advantage and if someone isn't using that advantage then they should just derank as well
Evyi (EUW)
: > [{quoted}](name=doby flonk u mom,realm=EUNE,application-id=NzaqEm3e,discussion-id=7EzmtrKy,comment-id=00000000,timestamp=2019-11-06T10:24:54.880+0000) > > Apparently not, here is a screenshot from my alt, with which I am (more or less) terrorizing the ranked players. > > https://gyazo.com/5883a8729865e0571fbd5b40b5cc783e
??? Im saying that I did not get banned for those games, I'm legit showing the client with my own profile, the only reason I made this profile is to troll ranked and show that Riot will do nothing about it. I doubt I will ever get banned on this account btw
: We all know though that RIOT won't do anything about inters/trolls/boosted accounts. They just want you to stop flaming while they ruin your games.
: Well... Once you declare such a rule, it will turn into a sport: find a bad player and kill him 8 times before 10:00 to prove your skill.
It's extremely %%%%ing difficult to win a game when all 5 team members are trying to kill a single person, you know staying under tower and farming minions under the tower and manipulating the wave isn't too difficult, if it is then just get deranked because this basic shit is so easy to do, and if you can't do it then you don't deserve your rank.
: off meta isn't bannable, score alone doesn't matter, game objective is to destroy nexus, not to gain as many kills as possible, playing first time on champ/role isn't bannable, other than those ye.
It should be bannable because things like this ruin the game and lose people lp, score matters because once a carry gets 8 kills at 10 minutes unless you have dedicated team comp to killing that carry you auto lose the game so yes score really does matter quite a lot actually
Evyi (EUW)
: Its not necessary to get a ban , Well everybody has some bad days , it happens for me even when i was diamond , but the only reason u can get banned is when u int for more then 3 games
Apparently not, here is a screenshot from my alt, with which I am (more or less) terrorizing the ranked players. https://gyazo.com/5883a8729865e0571fbd5b40b5cc783e
Rioter Comments
: @doby , well actually in real world , it is needed to spend some certain times to become Bond with some one , so i guess you tried to use the real mechanism here , Which is Both Good & also would not be that well too . for example it wouldn't be good cause this make the game More Grinding (& Grind is boring & joy killing to players) in other side , you need to be doing some thing to become bond with your main or the champ btw , so in that case taking care of certain things on a champion would be a must . but not grinding to 100k or buying things to make champ bond (cause we feel it is bond to Gold & it calls Gold Digging ! ) so its good to take care of champion in better ways . like playing the champ one time a day on any liked mode for a week or for highest Bond level , doing it for a month . also if mastery would be important , mastery lvl 3 would be the highest lvl enough for Ultimate (True Sincere & Everlasting ) Bond Level . in that lvl it would be nice that even champions ask from their summoner to do some thing possible in game for their favor :) For example : buy me an (certain) item if you could - or put a ward in a certain marked place in map - or atk rift scuttler/wolfs/drake & by doing that the champion get a little buff in returning the favor, for example : increasing the Health/Manna regeneration - or gives you a potion(Something like cleptomancy rune) or reduce CC effect & duration on himself/herself - or increases the total damage dealt with a bonus Damage deal Or bonus damage taken reduction , btw some random buffs from them to make game more exiting & Fun .{{sticker:vlad-salute}} Sincerely .
That would be a bit op in ranked, but it sounds like an amazing idea for a champion, they could call it a summoner champion paying tribute to the old lore :D
: Hello Summoners . About Champions~Summoners Conversation , I Actually Love It . Specially when the Champion is Your Main and you Love it . the Conversation Champion starts , make it Feels They're Alive & Real ! I & Way Too Many Many Players Adore it ! when the champion talks to you it feels : You're Not Alone ! The Champ is Your Company through all that Happens . maybe some of Champion Quotes are a few Blurry & needs some More Explicitly Speakings & Precise Identifications to make it a Super Realistic Conversation with You . In that case , it's good to have voice line like : ◘Quotes with More Insights & Depth & Feelings (Like Aurelion Sol{{champion:136}}, Karthus{{champion:30}} , Amumu{{champion:32}} ) ◘or with more Wisdom & Actually Good Advises (Like Ryze{{champion:13}} ) ◘Or Champions ask Good Questions (which doesn't need your answers , & just to make you think of it , is Great) ◘or Champions Share some of their Best Experiences And Opinions(according to their lore) With You to maybe You Both Find a Mutual Understandings & Point of View . It will make Wonderful Moments when The Champions & His/Her Summoner , **Actually Touch !** and also makes the game more Joyful . these Quotes Are Good Stuff to Help Summoners & Their Main Champions , **Bond Together ! ** on other side , unfortunately many Champions doesn't talk with summoner & they just speak some lifeless Empty words of Violence or Meaningful teases like : Bow to the void or i want to Devour/fight it ... also there are Other Champions that when they{{champion:150}} Speak , i have no idea rather than meh .. But they might be Cute in some Views . Hope the Voice Lines & their subjects contain these points . Thanks for Reading . Sincerely .
They should add special lines to champions you get 100k mastery points on, or certain milestones like 100k then another line at 250k and so on, that way the more you play the closer you feel to the champion.
: What will the TFT ranked rewards be? (Season 1)
Congrats on your efforts, and I hope you get rewards for your hard work, but those rewards should appear in TFT not in League of Legends, maybe 1 or 2 small things would be fine to bring into league, but any more would be kinda unfair for the league players who cannot work on TFT as much as on League. Blizzard let you get a visual item in WoW for playing their card game and that was that, I feel like riot should stick to the same principle as Blizzard.
: > [{quoted}](name=doby flonk u mom,realm=EUNE,application-id=NzaqEm3e,discussion-id=35E8yBGd,comment-id=0007,timestamp=2019-11-05T12:54:19.327+0000) > > Is this you on an alt account, I might start doing this to see if I get punished. > > I remember back in the day when you wanted to smurf in CSGO and couldn't pay for another copy you would intentionally derank and smurf from there and the derank process was really fun itself, so I'll see how low I can go before ban. Yep that's me. You can feed indefinitely as long as instant feedback doesn't flag you. And that only happens when you feed hard for entire game without doing much damage or getting kills/assists etc.
Ye I teseted it out a while back, I was levelling an account and wondered if they would actually ban me, so I just began running it down and went 0/23/3 and did not get banned. Then I tested it out on a fresh account and it turned out that if you actually get 0 kp then they will ban you for inting, I did the same thing with even less deaths I went 0/14/0 and I got 14 dayed for Intentional feeding. Their system is so flawed its funny, I Saw a person posting about getting banned for going 0/6/0 with kalista support, so It not only lets the culprits roam but it also bans the innocent, a bit like their verbal abuse system.
: Riot doesn't ban players for trolling your games. They are lying to you.
Is this you on an alt account, I might start doing this to see if I get punished. I remember back in the day when you wanted to smurf in CSGO and couldn't pay for another copy you would intentionally derank and smurf from there and the derank process was really fun itself, so I'll see how low I can go before ban.
: {{champion:32}} {{champion:42}} {{champion:427}} {{champion:429}} {{champion:57}} {{champion:421}} {{champion:72}} {{champion:48}}
Gryndall (EUNE)
: What I should do? I don't know.
You should expand your champion pool, I may sound like the biggest hypocrite since I only play Camille, but with Camille if I get a lead it's most likely gonna win the game, however with a support, you don't carry because you are good at the champion, you carry because you pick the best situational support that helps the entire team, if you have very squishy teammates then Zyra would be an awful pick since you can't peel and your whole team gets one shot, however, if you have mainly AD champions in all roles and a tank in the jungle then maybe Zyra would be viable, but even then 2 tanks would be better than 1. The reason maining a champion like Camille is good is because she can be an engager and a peeler, and if there already is a better tank on her team she does enough damage to carry the fight. What I am doing is bad because if they pick Poppy I auto lose, but what you are doing is worse because Zyra has like 100x more worse situations than Camille. Just expand your champion pool.
: will i be able to play urf within few hours?
I assume 28th in NA local time, so we EU people get the short end... as always :/
: It's not that clean, it's just the brush tool in photoshop. If you zoom in you can clearly see the brush lines.
well, I don't use photoshop so to a regular dude like me it looks like removed the names with surgical precision :D
Rioter Comments
: Just some things: 1. You can just report him for Negative Attitude if it's 2. Clearly he ment it sarcastic 3. Your aren't allowed to share summoner names in your screenshot. And you currently are breaking forum rules here. fix: https://i.imgur.com/eL6DjLX.png" [link](https://i.imgur.com/eL6DjLX.png)
btw that shit looks clean af, how did you do it?
: Just some things: 1. You can just report him for Negative Attitude if it's 2. Clearly he ment it sarcastic 3. Your aren't allowed to share summoner names in your screenshot. And you currently are breaking forum rules here. fix: https://i.imgur.com/eL6DjLX.png" [link](https://i.imgur.com/eL6DjLX.png)
thanks, bro, I changed it, I guess none of the admins saw it so I got off clean
Sunwise (EUNE)
: in addition of: 1. Stop pinging me for a Gank at Lv2 while your're under the Enemy turret. 2. Stop making me do the first move and soak the entire Laner damage to die and tell me "**GJ**" after you getting the kill like it was worth. 3. Listen to my Pings when I tell you **(Danger)** because as a Jungler, I totally know that you will be ganked **RIGHT NOW**, Instead of dying and saying "**jg difference**" while you're pushing without vision. P.S. Nothing is better than a Jungler that plays in a Lane and understand what to do when his Jungler comes, People shall learn Jungle and suffer from their Laners, Then try to learn a Lane.
: They do not correct them. There are already a lot of such cases. I don’t even know what to think, it seems that the Riot closes its eyes to it. I like games of this genre, and I played the first Dota for a very long time, but Dota 2 appeared, and I didn’t like it, I don’t even know why, but I continue to watch all the tournaments and follow this game. But I play the League of Legends. Why did I say that? And to the fact that if such bugs appear in DotA 2, this will instantly be fixed, literally within a few days, well, if the problem is very complicated, then in the next patch it will be fixed. I can’t understand why in the League of Legends, God already knows how many years, there is a Hitbox problem. People no longer even pay attention to it, and simply ridicule this situation. Riot, you should be more serious about your product, as it is used by millions around the world.
American company > Chinese company Dota 2 League of legends
Rioter Comments
CJXander (EUNE)
: 30k likes and 1,2k dislikes! Excellent. Funny fact for you sir, humans in general, are following and adopting STUPID things and stupid people, not the smart counterpart! Tyler1 has a huge fan base, because he's negative and "entertaining" for them. Big count doesn't necessarely mean quality, or even remotely that is the right choice. Just as for the fact most of league players reside in silver/gold, ofc they will agree with him, because they are frustrated little kids, and as soon as they see some popular douchebag having a similar point of view that fits with their little frustration and the disability to get any self accomplishment, they will find confort into his words or opinion. To give you another example of how much of baboons people can be, back in the days when Elon Musk gave the normies a chance to ask him questions about the Mars program, guess what the normies asked about? "why aren't you giving jobs to foreigners" and that kind of stupid SJW shit. You should by now realize that MASS = STUPIDITY. 90% of this community have no clue about what's best for this game, or even have the slightest idea about what it is like to lead a business. Kinda tired of average human thinking.
Ok so democracy is %%%%%%ed and one person should decide everything for everyone since everyone is stupid and don't know what they want. Oh wait thats fascism ahh cool.
Rioter Comments
: Yes u are correct I have been chat banned twice, but let me make this clear the only times I have been banned was due to me eather 1 defending myself against a toxic player or I have defended other players against toxic people dont think for one second I dont understand the SC I fully support it but riot has a policy where is punished both players for arguing with each other a lot of the time meaning the play that not muted the player and reported him and has just defended himself is banned also.
Imagine if they allowed plugins, someone would legit code a chat that is not monitored and like 90% of the player base would download that chat. Just imagining it makes me euphoric
Arkatorax (EUW)
: Final strike and perma banned S1 account with 4k games played and over 1k invested DEVASTATED
I have 12 banned accounts now, and I know that I can never be reformed, I just wait to get banned, however I also have an alt account that I use for clash and time rewards and skins, on that account I have the chat moved off the screen and the enter key unbound, that way I can get skins and timed events on that account without it being bannable. Not a good solution, the better solution would be to stop banning people but riot is so obsessed with restricting trash talk because of their dystopian fantasy of a world were no one flames, I get banned every 4 months because even if I try to not be toxic It's impossible in an environment like this.
Shamose (EUW)
: > without taking into account the investment players have put into the account Who cares about that though? Being a rich asshole with a lot of free time makes it right? > Granted I was an arse but a bit over the top to ban me for 1 single game. It's not for one game. You have a history as you said in your thread.
He is trying to say that he is not a rich asshole, he is saying that over the years he has been saving money for skins and stuff and all that stress of saving and time it took him to collect it is diminished because they banned him. Ye idk abt the second one, I have flamed harder in games and not even gotten chat restrict so you might be right that its not just 1 game.
: A tiny platform on botlane won't change caitlyns 1 item burst potential.
Have you thought about maybe a tiny platform in which there is probably a jungler or support? These platforms are the dumbest shit ever.
Rioter Comments
Uraraka (EUNE)
: It isn't problem of matchmaking because smurf accounts are treated same as normal accounts. Unless smurf accounts are flagged and matched only with smurfs, this kind of unfair games will continue.
But then someone on a winning streak will get shit on because they purposely mat... oh wait that already happens
: well good for you, but that's not how it's suppose to be. It's 5v5 anything else is a disadvantage even if you can manage a 3v5 "easily" in all cases
Better punishment for afkers would be better than fixing the remake system, while it's nice to ff at 3 and I would love to be able to ff at any point in the game if someone has been afk for more than 5 minutes, (hey another system that CSGO got right and league didn't) I think that the punishment is still not harsh enough, in those 20 minute for 5 games penalties I could go to the shop or make a coffee or play a better game in the time that I have to wait.
: You're literally saying that you would end it if you mained the champion he is maining. I doubt they will delete this, but i for sure would understand if they do. Look up "communist China" once more, buddy and stop ruining positive posts with your whining.
I am mainly talking about the censorship of communist china, like Riot you fail to accept any sort of context in anything, and like riot would probably ban someone for talking about a topic. smh
Pxerkza (EUNE)
: next time your internet drops or your power goes out i bet you would be thrilled to lose all your seasonal rewards for it lets do it
How about separating afk bans from other bans, so you only lose time if you afk, a punishment fitting the crime, I posted about how there should be incremental punishment for multiple-time offenders. I don't really care about seasonal rewards, but, to the people that do don't you think that stealing your rewards from you is kinda shitty since all you did was say a "naughty word".
LNRG Amos (EUW)
: LF Duo Mate i'm supp currently at s1
When I get to 30 (currently 27) I'll carry you to gold 1, just add me my euw is Dobbson.
: Is this new league mobile thing cross platform?
I think that it will be connected across mobile and console but not pc. Bye-bye skins, we wouldn't be able to extort our customers for even more money without making them start from scratch, after all we are owned by cancer also known as tencent.
: remake system is so shitt
I won a 3v5 easily, well the other two players were Yuumi + Garen so idk.
Dekara3 (EUW)
: Dont play ranked.
Majority of smurfs are people who were banned not people who want to trash on low elo, so to find the source of the problem stop banning players.
Dagòn (EUNE)
: Copyright. That's why.
Lmao, tencent cant get copyrighted, they are in china, why do you think they ripped off countless games and got away with it.
Show more

doby flonk u mom

Level 72 (EUNE)
Lifetime Upvotes
Create a Discussion